See if you can solve this

Spoiler:

ask the question "who is the liar?" , if the bird says that he's not the liar then he probably is the liar and when the bird says that the bird besides it is the liar, then he's the truth teller. ^^

my question will be '' Can I have some cheese?''

You tell them to "point at heaven if you are the good bird and point at hell if you are the bad bird". In this case both of the birds are gonna point at heaven, because one the one that lies is gonna do the opposite of pointing at hell.

It will also work if you ask one bird to tell what door the other will choose and then do the opposite.

Say: "Who likes heaven here"
Both obviously likes heaven, but one will not put up their hand because it is lying that he likes heaven(SO he answered that he hates heaven). The other will put up the hand because it likes heaven. The truth is the one raising the hand while the lie is the one not raising the hand. Quite a tricky riddle I suppose but the solution is asking something that is the same expected output but with different programmed output. More of like Logic Error if you know ICT

Anyways for the fun of it A great solution

Spoiler:

Uhhhh . . . .you can only ask ONE bird ONE question you may not say question aloud to both. . .keep it in mind

Bird that doesn't lie can you not show me the doors to heaven.

The bad bird will obviosly say that he doesnt lie because he lies and he will show the doors to heaven cause hill be lieng about them not being the doors to heaven.

My question would be:
"How many food we have?"
and i wont care what he says i'd just stay there untill i get bored. lol.

I've have the answer to this now. i'll post it later :p

FaenT wrote:

Uhhhh . . . .you can only ask ONE bird ONE question you may not say question aloud to both. . .keep it in mind

Yes, so the false bird if you ask him, he will not put up his had, if it is a true bird he does.

NUF SAID

-endzeit- wrote:

NUF SAID

Thanks dude! OMFG, I never though the solution was that easy. I was wondering for hours, but then, i saw your post. It changed my whole life.
+rep, you are amazing!

Bazinga wrote:

You tell them to "point at heaven if you are the good bird and point at hell if you are the bad bird". In this case both of the birds are gonna point at heaven, because one the one that lies is gonna do the opposite of pointing at hell.

It will also work if you ask one bird to tell what door the other will choose and then do the opposite.

Only second solution works

First thing is, that it is no question at all and second is, that the "bad" bird will lie about him being the bad bird, so hes pointing at hell

I'm right.

Yay

Why does Yu-Gi-Oh suddenly come to my mind...

P.S: I know that chapter from Yu-Gi-Oh was based on this story.

the right one will go to hell becoz he got big nose like pinoccio (dunno the spelling)