Heyho everyone, didn't know where to post this, so move this if necessary.
I was thinking about what kind of merchant is missing in Dota and I finally came up with some stuff:

Click this link to view merchant suggestion list

For Dota2 ofc, all the suggested items may be integrated into the normal shop.
Hope you like my ideas.
Review if you will.

Ok first of all your magical scope way to imba imagine it on sniper or ench.... you should limit it to certain heroes or reduce the range , thermal optics should be also reduced like to 1000 sight not 1200, doomhammer = upg of quelling not a seperate item, that gem should be an upgrade for normal gem but that it keeps the true sight too, don't really understand the fake ironwood branch, it drops the raiper but heroes see it as ironwood branch? And to lazy to read the mortar i'll get back to you about that

banebu wrote:

Ok first of all your magical scope way to imba imagine it on sniper or ench.... you should limit it to certain heroes or reduce the range

Ok it's rly op on sniper on ench, so let's say it doesn't stack with take aim and impetus.
Will fix this soon.

banebu wrote:

thermal optics should be also reduced like to 1000 sight not 1200,

errr... wtf are u talking about?
This item only gives u the same vision at night as you have at day + a true strike active with a huge cd.

banebu wrote:

doomhammer = upg of quelling not a seperate item, that gem should be an upgrade for normal gem but that it keeps the true sight too

no-upgrades-ever.com
seperate items have more flexibility on heroes then upgrades.

banebu wrote:

don't really understand the fake ironwood branch, it drops the raiper but heroes see it as ironwood branch?

It drops INSTEAD of the rapier or a gem. Enemy hereos will see it as a simple branch, even in your inventory.

banebu wrote:

And to lazy to read the mortar i'll get back to you about that

Dude, no offense, but if you don't have the time to read and think about what you just read, simply don't review it yet.
Read it when you have enuff time, and read it carefully, so this will avoid missunderstandings.
greez,
meph

meph90 wrote:

banebu wrote:

thermal optics should be also reduced like to 1000 sight not 1200,

errr... wtf are u talking about?
This item only gives u the same vision at night as you have at day + a true strike active with a huge cd.

yes same vision in day is 1200 thats just too much

meph90 wrote:

banebu wrote:

doomhammer = upg of quelling not a seperate item, that gem should be an upgrade for normal gem but that it keeps the true sight too

no-upgrades-ever.com
seperate items have more flexibility on heroes then upgrades.

I don't agree the take up more invent space..
[quote="meph90"]

banebu wrote:

don't really understand the fake ironwood branch, it drops the raiper but heroes see it as ironwood branch?

It drops INSTEAD of the rapier or a gem. Enemy hereos will see it as a simple branch, even in your inventory.[/qoute]
Then it's to cheap

Are you the AUTHOR of that thread in PLAYDOTA??

Ok will start reviewng but a part of items togheter,and some speratly :
-most of them focus on increasing range ,dmg so already a very bad ideea,the dota map is constructed along-side the range of an hero so you can bearly see an enemy hero from the middle lanes and so on.

The mortar is to expensive will never be bought,hard to use,you will get faster raped by a right clicking hero than you having time to set up the dmg .

The doomhammer,is way to imba,because it deals more dmg to enemy hero's,especially that fcking explode tree with 13 sec silence???!!! , you ever heard of doom? it bearly goes over 12 sec and it's doombringer ultimate.So totaly usless item.

The rammstein is using mana and only on melle and it doesnt have it's use,it's better to make it as a quelling blade , 1 k gold or 1,500 k gold for all kind of heroes so that supoprts cand do better pushing and tanks aswelll.

The scope with the vision around the map is imba,it's like countering gangs always,so it's to imba.

The gem that sees ilussion is maybe a good ideea but needs to cost more .

And lastly the fake ironcranch and the sausages are just lame ideas,in my opinion they aren't worth putting on the table.


This is a complete review,i know you will not agree with it,or you will think that i am an idiot cause 93% of your ideas aren't good. But i'm just telling my opinion and mabe it containts some truth aswell.

Magic Scope- Too OP, you are making certain heroes to be able to hit towers like Sniper, that's making the title "Sniper" a shame. Melee heroes who are already at a disadvantage of reaching Ranged heroes will have more disadvantage. There is a reason why Ranged heroes are fragile, and that is because they are ranged heroes . Most of the ranged heroes also have disables of various kinds to kite the melee around. If disables aren't enough, Lothars/Dagger will help one out o.O T-D

Spikes-Don't find any use of spending 1K for 5 more range and 15 damage... really :/ T-D

Monocle- Won't find it useful as your vision normally gets obstructed by trees in the day, if it's wards that have 200+ more vision than the standard one I would purchase it but for 300-400 gold, not 700. T-D.

Really don't like all of them basically, but will explain further later.

@Blood I hope you mean op for doomhammer not useless...

banebu wrote:

@Blood I hope you mean op for doomhammer not useless...

yes i mean op not useless,if it wasnt understood already

Blood4u wrote:

This is a complete review,i know you will not agree with it,or you will think that i am an idiot cause 93% of your ideas aren't good.

Why should I?
You know what your problem is? You got no humor or you didn't get behind the idea, aslike most of the other reviewers.
If I would have wanted to create uncriticzable items, I'd been more serious on that.
This 'new merch' was kinda humorous fun stuff, but unfortunatelly I didn't expect this place to be screwed like this, nvm.
I pushed this a bit to increase the sarcasm, but noone seems to have noticed that so my job here is done.

I noticed it i love the sausages I always thought an item like that is needed would be cool if it worked on towers too

meph90 wrote:

Blood4u wrote:

This is a complete review,i know you will not agree with it,or you will think that i am an idiot cause 93% of your ideas aren't good.

Why should I?
You know what your problem is? You got no humor or you didn't get behind the idea, aslike most of the other reviewers.
If I would have wanted to create uncriticzable items, I'd been more serious on that.
This 'new merch' was kinda humorous fun stuff, but unfortunatelly I didn't expect this place to be screwed like this, nvm.
I pushed this a bit to increase the sarcasm, but noone seems to have noticed that so my job here is done.

I never smile,i don't have humor, you should be carefull when asking reviews i'm always taking them serious.
If you like humor go to sarcastic sites.
I konw how to be funny aswell but not when reviewing.